Pixel 9a vs Pixel 9: There’s a clear winner for me

The Pixel lineup has expanded with the arrival of the new Pixel 9a, adding another layer of complexity to the purchase decision. Should you opt for the budget-friendly Pixel 9a, or invest a bit more in the Pixel 9, which boasts superior specs on paper?

I’ve made my choice, and it was an easy one. While we haven’t yet conducted a full review of the Pixel 9a, I’m confident in my recommendation based on specifications, pricing, and my personal usage patterns. However, individual preferences will always vary, but I believe most users will find my reasoning compelling.

Same, but different

The Pixel 9a and Pixel 9 share several key features, yet they also exhibit notable differences. Both devices feature a 6.3-inch 120Hz display with 2,700 nits of peak brightness. They are both powered by the Tensor G4 chipset, providing ample performance for the majority of users. Both models offer 128GB and 256GB storage options and are guaranteed seven years of software updates.

However, the Pixel 9 is undeniably the more premium device. Its camera system appears more advanced on paper, although a comprehensive review of the Pixel 9a is necessary to fully assess the real-world impact. Based on our experience with the Pixel 8a’s camera, which excelled in its price range, I anticipate the same from the Pixel 9a.

The Pixel 9 does offer 12GB of RAM vs the 8GB you get with the Pixel 8a. More RAM is better for on-device AI tasks and to future-proof the device. The Pixel 9 also has faster charging speeds (27W wired vs. 17W, and 12.5W wireless vs. 7.5W), an ultrasonic fingerprint scanner that’s faster and more accurate than the Pixel 9a’s optical scanner, and additional features like Satellite SOS.

While better on paper, we have to take pricing into account as well. The Pixel 9 comes with a significant price premium. At $800, it’s $300 more expensive than the Pixel 9a, representing a 60% increase. The crucial question is whether these added features justify the extra cost.

We also have to consider the fact that the Pixel 9a has a leg up on the Pixel 9 in a few areas. It has a significant advantage in battery capacity, as it boasts a 5,100mAh battery compared to the Pixel 9’s 4,700mAh cell. Given that both phones share the same display and chipset, which are power-intensive components, the Pixel 9a is likely to deliver superior battery life. Also, the Pixel 9a launched with Android 15, meaning its final software update will likely be Android 22, while the Pixel 9, launching with Android 14, is expected to conclude with Android 21.

Pixel 9a vs Pixel 9: For me, the choice is clear

For me, the Pixel 9a is the clear winner. It provides 90% of the Pixel 9’s experience at a $300 discount. The Pixel 9’s extra features aren’t essential for my needs, and I value the Pixel 9a’s enhanced battery life.

The Pixel 9a is a versatile device that fulfills all my requirements. The Tensor G4 chipset offers sufficient performance, and the camera should deliver excellent results in various lighting conditions. While the charging speeds are slightly slower than the Pixel 9, it’s not a significant drawback for me.

My priorities include display quality, battery life, camera performance, software support, and overall performance. The Pixel 9a excels in these areas, offering near-flagship capabilities at a mid-range price.

While I recommend the Pixel 9a for most users, exceptions exist. If the Pixel 9’s additional features are worth the $300 premium for you, then it’s a fantastic choice. Features like Satellite SOS or advanced camera capabilities might be crucial for certain individuals. Ultimately, the best choice depends on individual needs and preferences.

Of course, we have to take design into account as well. While most people don’t care about that, some do. A lot. It’s a matter of personal preference, but I think the Pixel 9 does look better. Sure, the two phones are almost exactly alike, but the small differences are noticeable to someone with an eye for detail. For example, the bezels around the display are smaller on the Pixel 9, so while the two phones have the same-sized display, the overall footprint of the Pixel 9 is a tad smaller.

Then there’s the back. The Pixel 9 has a protruding camera that I think looks quite nice. It adds a bit of personality to the device and is an eye-catcher for me personally. The Pixel 9a has no camera bar whatsoever, making the back of it look a bit bland — although this is a matter of personal preference. And the back of the Pixel 9 is made of glass for a premium look and feel, while the Pixel 9a’s is made of plastic.

That’s my take, what’s yours? Which of the two phones would you rather get? Cast your vote in the poll above and share your reasoning in the comments.