Steam Deck vs Nintendo Switch: How do they compare?

While Nintendo has traditionally reigned supreme in the world of handheld consoles, Valve’s Steam Deck has become a legitimate alternative to the Nintendo Switch. How do the two consoles differ, and which one actually makes sense to buy in 2023?

Steam Deck vs Nintendo Switch: Performance

In terms of performance, there’s almost no contest. The Switch’s Tegra X1 chip, 4GB of RAM, and 32GB of internal storage were sub-par when the console shipped in 2017, and absolutely pale next to the Steam Deck, which shipped in 2022. You can play games like Street Fighter 6 or Cyberpunk 2077 on a Steam Deck — the Switch sometimes struggles with the low-detail (though still attractive) Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom. Even then you have to slide the Switch into its TV dock to get maximum performance, since it throttles down in portable mode.

The OLED Switch fares marginally better. It gets slightly more internal storage, a more power-efficient Tegra X1 Plus processor, and one of the few things it can lord over the original Steam Deck, which is of course its beautiful OLED screen that offers better colors and contrast. If you buy the Steam Deck OLED, even that advantage disappears, if at a substantial price premium.

There’s a similar story when it comes to battery life. Standard LCD Switches get anywhere between 2.5 and 6.5 hours, and going with OLED extends that to between 4.5 and 9 hours. The Steam Deck LCD might not even last 2 hours when playing an intense 3D game like God of War, and isn’t going to run any longer than 8, but the OLED Deck can reach anywhere from 3 to 12.

One thing to factor into a Switch purchase is the absolute necessity of buying a microSD card. 32 or 64GB of internal storage is going to fill up in a heartbeat — Tears of the Kingdom alone consumes 16.3GB.

Steam Deck vs Nintendo Switch: Control

Superficially the two consoles have similar input schemes, including twin analog sticks and an assortment of face, shoulder, and trigger buttons. They’re both well-equipped to play most of the games they run, and when better controllers are needed, it’s relatively easy to buy and connect wired or wireless add-ons. It should be noted that the Switch’s default Joy-Con inputs are removable, although primarily for wireless use, or replacing them if they develop the console’s infamous controller drift.

The Switch is better equipped for local multiplayer, since it comes with a TV dock and (in a pinch) a built-in stand for table viewing. There’s nothing blocking similar play on the Steam Deck, but there’s no built-in stand, and you’ll need to buy your own cable or dock to connect it to a TV or monitor.

The Steam Deck does benefit from twin trackpads, which offer more precise control than the Switch for things like strategy and FPS games. And while both systems support using a mouse and keyboard, only the Steam Deck can make extensive use of that, since it’s essentially a handheld PC. Most Switch games won’t work with either peripheral type.

Steam Deck vs Nintendo Switch: Games

For some people, this is going to be the deciding factor over anything else. Many first-party Nintendo games are exclusive to the Switch, and simply can’t be played on a Steam Deck without complicated (and potentially illegal) emulation. Examples include everything from Tears of the Kingdom and Super Mario Odyssey to Metroid Dread and Pokémon Legends: Arceus. There are third-party games on the platform, but some of those are available elsewhere.

The Switch requires a Switch Online subscription for online play and cloud saves. Among other perks, however, you get a library of classic NES, SNES, and Game Boy titles. The service costs $19.99 per year.

The Steam Deck has a few advantages, including no (inherent) subscription requirement, and access to the massive library of PC titles on Steam. Only some of these are “Deck Verified” — meaning they’re known to play well on the console — but even many non-verified games will work, and the compatibility list is continually expanding.

With a little effort, it’s possible to open the Steam Deck to non-Steam titles from sources like Xbox Game Pass and the Epic Games Store. In fact, when in Desktop Mode, the only serious barrier to what you can play is the Steam Deck’s specs. The console may be powerful enough for its cost, but don’t expect it to match a desktop gaming PC.

Steam Deck vs Nintendo Switch: Which should you choose?

The answer is complicated. If you want to play Nintendo franchises like Mario, Zelda, or Pokemon without emulation, the Switch is pretty much your only choice. When you go that route however, you’re sacrificing access to many games the Switch is functionally incapable of playing. Titles like Cyberpunk 2077 would be little more than a slideshow on a Switch.

Players after the best possible gaming experience should pick the Steam Deck. It’s faster, has more control options, and can potentially access an even larger library than the Switch, since as we’ve said it’s effectively a handheld PC. You’ll want to go with the OLED Deck if you can at all afford it, since on top of improved display and battery specs, it offers a slew of smaller refinements.

That brings us to a critical topic we haven’t covered yet: cost. The Steam Deck starts at $399, and can cost as much as $649 before adding options like a dock or extra controllers, never mind games. That’s cheap for a PC, yet expensive compared to the Switch, especially if you’re buying something for children to play on.

On Nintendo’s side, the top end is the OLED Switch ($348 at Amazon). The older launch model is $299.99, and there’s also the handheld-only Switch Lite ($197 at Amazon). That makes the platform pretty affordable, outdated specs notwithstanding.

Something that might balance out hardware costs is game pricing. Nintendo rarely discounts first-party titles, so a product like Super Mario Odyssey is still $59.99, despite being over six years old. Many PC games start at that price or less, and frequently go on sale. For people who buy many games every year, a Switch could rapidly become the more expensive pick. That’s without considering the Switch 2, which could ship as soon as 2024. A Steam Deck 2 probably won’t ship until 2025 or 2026, if not later.

FAQs